Method and system to publish a proxy bid and a reserve price

ABSTRACT

A auction system includes an auction price-setting purchase process and a fixed price purchase process for purchasing a buyer&#39;s proxy bid during an auction.

CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No.60/437,182, filed Dec. 31, 2002 and U.S. Provisional Application No.60/494,400 filed Aug. 11, 2003, which are incorporated herein byreference.

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates generally to the field of network-basedcommerce and, more specifically, to the facilitation of pricenegotiations between a buyer and a seller by a network-based auctionfacility.

BACKGROUND

Many network-based commerce systems have emerged in the past severalyears. Through network-based commerce systems, potential sellers canenter information about their product or service for potential buyers tobid on. The information submitted by potential sellers is thenorganized, stored and presented as a listing by the network-basedcommerce system. Potential buyers can search through the organizedseller information to find products or services on which they wish topurchase. A purchase price may be established with respect to aparticular listing utilizing one of a number of price-settingmechanisms. For example, a particular commerce system may support one ormore of a fixed price-setting mechanism (e.g., the seller publishes aprice at which the item is to be sold, this price being fixed) and anauction price-setting mechanism.

Considering an auction price-setting mechanism, once a bidder locates anitem (or listing) to bid on, the bidder can compete with other biddersfor the item by submitting bids during a specified auction time period.At the end of the specified auction time period, the highest bid bidderis notified and the transaction between the seller and the highest bidbidder is facilitated.

While the current network-based commerce systems work well, a number ofsignificant technical challenges to the automation of the commerceprocess remain. For example, many items in a network-based commercesystem providing an auction price-setting mechanism have at most one bidduring the specified auction time. An interested bidder must sometimeswait days for an auction to end even though his or her bid is the onlybid received. Also, there are many potential buyers who do not likeauction formats.

Another problem occurs when a seller sets an artificially high reserveprice for a product listing, which turns out to be higher than anybidder is willing to pay for the Rev. listing and/or higher than amarket price for the item. In this situation, the relevant item may notsell.

However, unlike traditional brick and mortar commerce locations thatgenerally have sales representatives to answer questions about a good orservice, network-based commerce systems (e.g., websites) may not havethe capability to ask questions about the good/service, or the provisionof such help functions may be expensive.

SUMMARY OF EMBODIMENTS THE INVENTION

Publishing a proxy bid in a network-based auction system is described.According to one aspect there is provided an auction system to presentan auction price-setting process and a fixed price purchase process forautomatically publishing at least one of a proxy bid information and areserve price if a high proxy bid is less than the reserve price beingassociated with a listing for an item during the network based auctionprice-setting process.

Other features of the present invention will be apparent from theaccompanying drawings and from the detailed description that follows.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The present invention is illustrated by way of example and notlimitation in the figures of the accompanying drawings, in which likereferences indicate similar elements and in which:

FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating an exemplary network-basedtransaction facility in the form of a network-based commerce system.

FIG. 2 is a database diagram illustrating an exemplary database for thetransaction facility.

FIG. 3 is a flow chart illustrating an exemplary method of receivinglisting information from a seller, indicating whether to offer the itemat a seller fixed-price offer.

FIG. 4 is a flow chart illustrating an exemplary method of generating abuyer preferred index page using category preferences or searchcriteria.

FIG. 5 is a flow chart illustrating an exemplary method of displayinguser interfaces for and operating a commerce system with an auctionprice-setting process and optionally a fixed price-setting process.

FIG. 6A is a flow chart depicting a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to adjust a seller fix-price offerin an auction.

FIG. 6B is a flow chart depicting a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to adjust a reserve price in anauction.

FIG. 6C depicts a flow chart illustrating a method, according to anexemplary embodiment of the present invention, to facilitate buyerproposal of an offer price.

FIG. 6D depicts a flow chart illustrating a method, according to anexemplary embodiment of the present invention, to adjust a reserve priceand/or a seller-fixed-price offer for a listing based on a buyerrequest.

FIG. 7A is a flow chart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to exchange reserve priceinformation of a seller and proxy bid information of a buyer.

FIG. 7B is a flow chart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to publish reserve priceinformation based on predetermined criteria.

FIG. 7C is a flow chart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to publish a fixed-price offerduring an auction price-setting process.

FIG. 8 is a flow chart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, for the operation of a listinganalyzer.

FIG. 9 is a flow chart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to facilitate seller-controlledpublication of question and answer information.

FIG. 10 illustrates an exemplary seller interface to receive informationon seller's offerings.

FIG. 11 illustrates an exemplary buyer interface to facilitate a buyerin locating items to purchase or bid on.

FIG. 12 illustrates an exemplary item list generated in response tobuyer's category selection or search criteria provided in the userinterface.

FIG. 13 illustrates an exemplary buyer interface used to receive buyerinformation including an indication to use the fixed-price purchaseprocess or the auction purchase process.

FIG. 14 shows a diagrammatic representation of machine in the exemplaryform of a computer system.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Publishing a seller fixed price offer and/or a reserve price in anetwork-based commerce system is disclosed. In the followingdescription, for purposes of explanation, numerous specific details areset forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the presentinvention. It will be evident, however, to one skilled in the art thatthe present invention may be practiced without these specific details.

Terminology

The term “user,” “buyer,” “seller,” and “bidder” shall be taken to referto any entity, human or automated, that contributes to, or participatesin, a transaction, communication or process.

The term “transaction” shall be taken to include any communication orexchange between two or more entities with a view to establishing abusiness agreement, an exchange of value or a commercial relationship.Accordingly, the word “transaction” shall be deemed to cover, but not belimited to, a purchase-and-sale transaction established as a result, forexample, of the placement of an advertisement or as a result of theconclusion of an auction process, the auction process being conductedacross a communications network or otherwise.

The term “data file” shall be taken to mean a collection of transactionlistings. Accordingly, the phrase “data file” shall be deemed to cover,but not be limited to, a collection of transaction listings, forexample, which is being propagated to a network-based transactionfacility.

Commerce System

FIG. 1 is block diagram illustrating an exemplary network-based commercesystem 10. While an exemplary embodiment of the present invention isdescribed within the context of a network-based commerce system 10, theinvention will find application in many different types ofcomputer-based, and network-based, facilities, platforms or marketplaces(commerce, transaction or otherwise).

The network-based commerce system 10, in an exemplary embodiment,includes one or more of a number of types of front-end servers that eachincludes at least one Dynamic Link Library (DLL) to provide certainfunctionality. Page servers 12 deliver web pages (e.g., markup languagedocuments), picture servers 14 dynamically deliver images to bedisplayed within web pages, listing servers 16 facilitate category-basedbrowsing of listings, search servers 20 that handle search requests tothe network-based commerce system 10 and facilitate keyword-basedbrowsing of listings, and application servers 18 provide an intelligentinterface to the back-end of the network-based commerce system 10.E-mail servers 22 provide, inter alia, automated e-mail communicationsto users of the network-based commerce system 10. Application servers 18provide a set of functions (e.g., defined by an Application ProgramInterface (API)) for querying the network-based commerce system 10.These queries include getting information on items, getting userinformation, listing items, etc. Application functions are invoked viaan HTTP transport protocol request from an application.

The page servers 12, picture servers 14, listing servers 16, applicationservers 18, search servers 20, e-mail servers 22 and database engineserver 26 may individually, or in combination, act as a communicationengine to facilitate communications between, for example, the clientmachine 38 and the network-based commerce system 10. In addition, thepage servers 12, picture servers 14, listing servers 16, applicationservers 18, search servers 20, e-mail servers 22 and database engineserver 26 may individually, or in combination, act as a transactionengine to facilitate transactions between, for example, the clientmachine 38 and the network-based commerce system 10. Furthermore, thepage servers 12, picture servers 14, listing servers 16, applicationservers 18, search servers 20, e-mail servers 22, and database engineserver 26 may individually, or in combination, act as a display engineto facilitate the display of items (e.g., as listings) on a clientmachine 38.

The back-end servers include a database engine server 26, a search indexserver 24 and a credit card database server 28, each of which maintainsand facilitates access to a respective database.

The network-based commerce system 10 may be accessed by a clientprogram, such as for example a browser 36 (e.g., a Internet Explorerbrowser distributed by Microsoft Corp. of Redmond, Wash.) that executeson a client machine 38 and accesses the network-based commerce system 10via a network such as, for example, the Internet 34. Other examples ofnetworks that a client may utilize to access the network-based commercesystem 10 include a wide area network (WAN), a local area network (LAN),a wireless network (e.g., a cellular network), or the Public SwitchedTelephone Network (PSTN) network.

Further, while the environment described above with reference to FIG. 1employs a client-server architecture, it will be appreciated that apeer-to-peer (or distributed) architecture may also be employed tosupport the network-based commerce system.

Database Structure

FIG. 2 is a database diagram illustrating an exemplary database 30,maintained by and accessed via the database engine server 26, which atleast partially implements and supports the network-based commercesystem 10.

The database 30 may, in one embodiment, be implemented as a relationaldatabase, and includes a number of tables having entries, or records,that are linked by indices and keys. In an alternative embodiment, thedatabase 30 may be implemented as a collection of objects in anobject-oriented database. FIG. 2 shows one embodiment of a database, itwill be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the invention canbe used with other database structures.

Central to the database 30 is a user table 54, which contains a recordfor each user of the network-based commerce system 10. A user mayoperate as a seller, buyer, or both, when utilizing the network-basedcommerce system 10. The database 30 also includes items tables 60 thatmay be linked to the user table 54. The items tables 60 may include aseller items table 52 and a bidder items table 58. A user record in theuser table 54 may be linked to multiple items that are being, or havebeen, listed or offered for sale via the network-based commerce system10. A link indicates whether the user is a seller or a bidder (or buyer)with respect to items for which records exist within the items tables60.

The database 30 also includes one or more category tables 47. Eachrecord within the category table 47 describes a respective category. Inone embodiment, a specific category table 47 describes multiple,hierarchical category data structures, and includes multiple categoryrecords, each of which describes the context of a particular categorywithin the one of the multiple hierarchical category structures. Forexample, the category table 47 may describe a number of real, or actual,categories to which item records, within the items tables 60, may belinked.

The database 30 also includes one or more attributes tables 49. Eachrecord within an attributes table 49 describes a respective attribute.In one embodiment, a specific attributes table 49 describes multiple,hierarchical attribute data structures, and includes multiple attributerecords, each of which describes the context of a particular attributewithin the one of the multiple hierarchical attribute structures. Forexample, the attributes table 49 may describe a number of real, oractual, attributes to which item records, within the items tables 60,may be linked. Also, the attributes table 49 may describe a number ofreal, or actual, attributes to which categories, within the categorytable 47, may be linked.

The database 30 also includes a note table 46 populated with noterecords that may be linked to one or more item records within the itemstables 60 and/or to one or more user records within the user table 54.Each note record within the note table 46 may include, inter alia, acomment, description, history or other information pertaining to an itembeing offered via the network-based commerce system 10, or to a user ofthe network-based commerce system 10. Also, the database 30 includes atargeted site table 67 populated with targeted site records that may belinked to one or more item records within the items tables 60 and/or toone or more user records within the user table 54.

A number of other tables are also shown to be linked to the user table54, namely a user past aliases table 48, a feedback table 50, a bidstable 56, an accounts table 64, an account balances table 62 and a batchitems table 40.

FIG. 3 shows a flowchart for an exemplary embodiment of a method toacquire listing information from a seller. The seller issues a listingrequest (block 100) to the commerce system 10, and the commerce system10 generates instructions (block 110) offering the seller the option tosell his item using an auction price-setting process and/or a fixedprice-setting process. After the instructions have been transmitted(block 120), and a page server 12 (see FIG. 1) facilitates the displayof the instructions, the seller decides whether to offer a bidder thechance to buy the item utilizing the fixed price-setting process (block130). In one embodiment, if the bidder options to buy the listed itemutilizing the fixed price-setting process, the auction for the listingis automatically closed.

The seller transmits a purchase process indicator by either anaffirmative (block 140) or a negative (block 150). The server (commercesystem 10) can receive and store in note table 46 of database 30 (FIG.2) this information for later use (block 160). The seller also transmitsother offering information, such as a description, picture, a reserveprice, and contact information to be collected and stored in thelistings tables 60 of the database 30 (see FIG. 2) (block 170).

FIG. 4 shows a flow chart showing one embodiment of a buyer'sinteraction with the network-based commerce system 10, which in theexemplary embodiment provides a web site to facilitate user interaction.The buyer locates the web site by inputting the commerce systemidentifier (e.g., a URL) (block 405) into the client program 36 runningon client machine 38 (see FIG. 1) which transmits the commerce systemidentifier (block 610) through the Internet 34 (See FIG. 1). Thenetwork-based commerce system 10 receives the transmission and a listingserver 16 (see FIG. 1) generates (block 420) a list of availablecategories of items stored in items table 60 (see FIG. 2) for buyerselection. The commerce system 10 (block 430) transmits the categorylist and transmits an interface, generated by page server 12 (see FIG.1), to allow the buyer to enter search for navigation criteria, whichmay the selectable from the category list, or may be independent of thecategory list (e.g., a text search). The buyer selects a categorypreference from the category list or generates search criteria (block440). The buyer then transmits (block 450) the category preferenceand/or search criteria, again, via the Internet 34 (see FIG. 1). Uponreceipt of the category preference and/or search criteria, the commercesystem 10 uses a search server 20 (see FIG. 1) to generate an item indexpage of relevant offerings including visual indicators displayed inrespect to items in which the seller is allowing a buyer to buy the itemat a seller fixed-price offer, utilizing a fixed price-setting process(block 460). The item index page is transmitted to the buyer (block480). After receiving the item index page (block 470), the buyergenerates a request for an item to purchase or bid on. Picture servers14 (see FIG. 1) can also be used to show the buyer pictures (ifavailable) of the item. The buyer's request is then transmitted (block490).

FIGS. 5A and 5B presented a flowchart illustrating an exemplary methodby which the buyer interfaces with the network-based commerce system 10,when a seller fixed-price offer is an alternative option to bidding.After the commerce system 10 receives the bidder's request (block 200)from the client machine 38, decision block 210 decides if there is stilltime remaining in an auction price-setting process for the relevant item(item requested by the bidder). Specifically, the auction price-settingprocess may be time limited. In this embodiment, if a predeterminedperiod of time has passed, the buyer will not be allowed to buy at theseller fixed-price offer. Instead the auction price-setting process willend and the highest bidder (if there is one) will be determined (block380). However, in alternative embodiments, the buyer is allowed to buyat the seller fixed-price offer after a predetermined period of time haspassed, as will be described below in conjunction with FIG. 6. If thereis time remaining, a determination is made in decision block 220 whethera prior bid has been received. In this embodiment, if a prior bid hasbeen received, then the seller fixed-price offer is no longer availableto the buyer and the buyer's only option is to bid and a second userinterface will be generated (block 390). If no prior bid has beenreceived, and the item has a seller fixed-price offer available, a firstuser interface will be generated (block 230). The commerce system 10will make the typical auction price-setting process available throughthe first user interface (block 240) and will make the fixedprice-setting process available to the client through the first userinterface (block 250). The seller fixed-price offer is retrieved for thefirst user interface (block 260). The first user interface is generatedas a markup language document suitable for viewing by the buyer (block270). The generated markup language document is then transmitted forviewing by the buyer on the client machine 38 using pages servers 12 onthe network-based commerce system 10 (block 280).

Referring again to decision block 220, if it is determined that aninitial bid value has been received, a second user interface will begenerated (block 390). The auction price-setting process is theninvoked, and made available through the second user interface (block400). The second user interface is generated as a markup languagedocument suitable for viewing by the buyer (block 270). The generatedmarkup language document is then transmitted to the buyer (block 280).

After the markup language document has been transmitted to the buyer, adetermination is made at decision block 420, based on the transmittedmarkup language document, whether the fixed price-setting process isavailable to the buyer. If the fixed price-setting process is availableto the buyer, the buyer then makes a determination at decision block 290whether to buy the item utilizing the fixed price-setting process (e.g.,at the seller fixed-price bronze offer) or utilizing the auctionprice-setting process (e.g., whether to bid on the item). If the buyerchooses to purchase the item using the fixed price-setting process, anindication to this end is transmitted to the commerce system 10.

If the fixed price-setting process is not available to the buyer (asdetermined in decision block 420) or fixed price-setting process isavailable, but the buyer chooses not to use the list option, the buyerprovides a bid (block 310). The bid is then transmitted to the commercesystem 10 (block 320).

Upon receiving a transmission at the network-based commerce system 10,from the buyer, a determination is made at decision block 330 whetherthe buyer has chosen the fixed price-setting process. If the buyer haschosen the fixed price-setting process, the auction price-settingprocess is stopped (block 340) and a transaction is established betweenthe buyer and the seller (block 410). Optionally, the commerce system 10can check the buyer's credit before stopping the auction.

If the buyer has not opted to use the fixed price-setting process, asdetermined by the commerce system 10 at decision block 330 (eitherbecause it wasn't available or he or she preferred to place a bidinstead), the bid is received (block 350). Optionally, if the bid isgreater than the seller fixed-price offer (and the fixed price-settingprocess is still available), the commerce system 10 may invite the buyerto use the fixed price-setting process. In one embodiment, upon receiptof the bid, the fixed price-setting process option is removed (block360) and a determination is made at decision block 370 to see if thereis any time remaining in the auction price-setting process. If there istime remaining, bids can be received and processed until expiration ofthe auction price-setting process. However, if there is no more timeremaining in the auction price-setting process, the highest valid bid isdetermined from the received bids (block 380), and a transaction isestablished between the highest bidder and the seller (block 410).

FIG. 6A is a flow diagram illustrating an exemplary method to just aseller fixed-price offer, provided within the context of a concurrentauction price-setting process, where the option remains for the buyer topurchase a listed item at the commerce system 10 for the sellerfixed-price of a during the auction price-setting process, even afterbids have been submitted. However, the fixed price-setting processoption may disappear if submitted bids surpass either the reserve priceor the fixed-price offer.

A seller client side 601, a buyer client side 603, and a server side 602separate FIG. 6A. At block 605, within the seller client side 601, aseller may provide an indication to adjust a seller fixed-price offerfor a listing when generating offer information. For example, a sellermay decide to adjust a seller fixed-price offer of a listing afterdetermining that the current seller fixed-price offer is higher than abuyer is willing to play and/or higher than a market price for the item.

At block 606, the commerce system 10 receives the listing information,including the indication that a reserve price and/or seller fixed priceoffer of the listing may be adjusted during the auction price-settingprocess. One exemplary embodiment of a method to receive and processlisting information from a seller at the commerce system 10 isillustrated in FIG. 3. The listing information, including reserve priceand/or fixed-price offer price information, may be collected and storedin the seller items table 52 of database 30.

At block 608, a buyer selects a buyer opt-in indication to opt into abinding agreement if the seller fixed-price offer is adjusted at orbelow a submitted bid of the buyer during the auction price-settingprocess. That is, when a buyer places a bid on an item, the buyer willbe given the option (e.g., via a bid confirmation page) to make the bidan opt-in bid or an opt-out bid. In one embodiment, if the buyer doesnothing, the bid defaults to being an opt-out bid, as will be described.

If a buyer opts-in, the buyer agrees that the placed bid is bindingregardless of whether an adjustment made to the reserve price or sellerfixed-price offer of an item during the auction price-setting process.If a buyer has opted out, this indicates the buyer's desire that aplaced bid not be binding in the event that an adjustment is made to thereserve price or the seller fixed-price offer. It should be understoodthat the buyer may submit a proxy bid for the item, in which case thecommerce system 10 will submit a bid (e.g., based on a predeterminedincrement) on the behalf of a buyer up to a maximum bid price set by thebuyer.

At block 610, the network-based commerce system 10 receives the buyerbid option, including an opt-in or opt-out bid preference. The bidoption information may be stored in the user table 54 of database 30 (atblock 612).

At block 614, the seller transmits an option to adjust the predefinedseller fixed-price offer of a listing for an item during an auctionprice-setting process.

At block 616, the commerce system 10 receives the option to adjust theseller fixed-price offer. At block 618, the commerce system 10 adjuststhe seller fixed-price offer based on the indication given by the sellerin block 614.

At block 619, the commerce system 10 determined whether the adjustedfixed-price offer is less then the proxy of the bidder. If the sellerfixed-price offer is lowered, but is still above the bidder's proxy bid,control passes to block 623. If the seller fixed-price offer is loweredand is less then the bidder's proxy, control passes to block 620.

At block 623, no action will be taken and the auction will continue. Thebids will stand, and the auction price-setting process will still showthe reserve price has not been met.

At block 620, a determination is made whether a buyer has submitted anopt-in bid. If an opt-in bid has been submitted, control passes to block622. If an opt-out bid has been submitted, control passes to block 628.At block 622, if the seller lowers the seller fixed-price offer to at orbelow the opt-in bidder's proxy bid, the high bidder will thenautomatically become the winner of the item and the agreement is binding(block 624). At block 625, the commerce system 10, via a page server 12,will show the auction price-setting process has ended for the item withthe seller fixed-price offer. At block 626, a transaction is establishedbetween the buyer and seller.

At block 627, the buyer is notified of being a winner of the listing.Notification may be performed via an email mechanism, instant messaging,peer-to-peer communications, update of the listing, or other well knownelectronic or non-electronic communications mechanisms well known tothose of ordinary skill in the art.

If the seller fixed-price offer is lowered (block 618), but is stillhigher than the opt-in bidder's high bid (block 622), the auctionprice-setting process will continue (block 630).

At block 620, if a buyer has opted out, the proxy bid of the buyer isnot binding if the price is lowered. At block 628, if the seller lowersthe seller fixed-price offer below the opt-out bidder's proxy bid, thecommerce system 10 will transmit a notification of the adjustment to thebuyer(s) (and/or other relevant parties) that have established proxybids at or greater than the adjusted seller fixed-price offer.

The relevant parties may include all of the buyers that have submitted abid for the item and/or watchers (e.g., individuals that are haveindicated an interest in the auction but may have not submit a bid). Therelevant parties may also include parties that are given specialconsideration during the auction for a variety of reasons.

If the seller lowers the seller fixed-price offer to a price that isstill greater than a buyer proxy bid, no special messaging is given tothe high bidder and the auction price-setting process continues asnormal, at block 630.

At block 634, the buyer (and/or relevant parties) receives notificationsof the adjustment of the reserve price and/or fixed-price offer.Notification may be performed via a email mechanism, instant messaging,peer-to-peer communications, update of listing, or other well knownelectronic or non-electronic communications mechanisms well known tothose of ordinary skill in the art.

At block 636, the buyer receives notification of being a winner of theoffering.

It should be understood that the seller fixed-price offer for thelisting may initially be set before or during the auction for the item.It should also be understood that the seller fixed-price offer will beavailable on the listing until the item is purchased or the auction forthe listing ends. The seller may further, during an auction, invoke andactivate the seller fix-price offer feature, as discussed above. Also,the fixed price-setting process option may be disabled if submitted bidssurpass either the reserve price or the fixed-price offer, as discussedabove in conjunction with FIG. 5. It should be understood that theseller may adjust the reserve price and/or the seller fixed-price offeras often as wanted.

It should be appreciated that the process flow of FIG. 6A may be usedwhen the seller options to adjust the reserve price. However, instead ofdesignating a winner (at block 624), ending the auction (at block 625),and initiating a transaction (at block 626), the commerce system 10 mayinform the bidders that the reserve has been met. Furthermore, if theseller fixed-price offer is lowered below the reserve price, the reserveprice will also be automatically lowered to the same amount as theseller fixed-price offer.

FIG. 6B is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to oneembodiment of the present invention, to adjust a reserve price in anauction. Operations on a seller client side 601, a buyer client side603, and a server side 602 are distinguished in FIG. 6B. At block 640, aseller adjust a reserve price for a listing. At block 642, the sellerreceives the seller's adjustment of the reserve price for the listing.At block 644, the reserve price is adjusted at the commerce system 10.

At block 646, if the buyer has submitted an opted-in bid, (as in block608), control passes to block 648. At block 646, if the buyer hassubmitted an opt-out bid, control passes to block 654. At block 648, ifthe reserve price is lowered below a maximum proxy bid submitted by thebuyer, at block 644, control passes to block 650. At block 650, thebuyer will remain the current high bidder, but the high bid will beraised to the adjusted reserve price, and the reserve will be noted asmet at block 652. The auction price-setting process is now binding. Atblock 648, if the reserve price is lowered, but is still above theopt-in bidder's proxy. The commerce system 10 will still show thereserve price is not yet met and the auction price-setting process willcontinue at block 658.

At block 654, if it is determined that the seller has lowered thereserve price below the proxy of the opt-out buyer, control passes toblock 656. At block 656, the proxy bid will be lowered to below theadjusted reserve price. For example, the proxy bid will be lowered toone dollar below the lowered reserve price. In one embodiment, inaddition to the email that will be sent to all bidders when the reservehas been lowered, there may also be messaging that will explain that theproxy bid has been changed. There may also be a capability to receivemore detailed information (e.g., a link to a WWW page generated by thepage server 12, that gives more detailed information to the bidder).

If the reserve price is lowered, but is still above the opt-out bidder'sproxy, at block 654 control passes to block 658. At block 658, theauction price-setting process will continue, the bids will stand, andthe commerce system 10 will still show reserve not met.

It should also be understood that the reserve price may be removed ordisabled from a listing. In this fashion, the auction facility 10 willnotify the parties that the reserve price has been met automatically orupon receiving the next bid for the item. This would mean, for example,that the current high bidder would be bound to purchase the listed itemat the current high bid price or the reserve price is automaticallyadjusted to be a specific amount (e.g., $1) above the current high bid(and the next bid that is placed will meet the reserve price). It shouldalso be understood that in one embodiment, the reserve price and/orseller fixed-price offer may also be increased. The reserve price and/orseller fixed-price offer for the listing may initially be set before orduring the auction price-setting process for the item. Further, theseller fix-price offer may be available on the listing until the item ispurchased or the auction price-setting process for the listing ends.Also, the bidders may be notified (e.g., via email, instant messenger,update of listing, etc) of any change in reserve price (at block 644),high bid (at block 650), and proxy bid (at block 656). It should beunderstood that the seller may adjust the reserve price and/or theseller fixed-price offer as often as wanted.

FIG. 6C is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to oneembodiment of the present invention, to receive buyer proposed offerprice. According to this method, a buyer may indicate a desire to aseller to purchase a listed item from the seller at a buyer-proposedoffer price, thereby negotiating with the seller to buy the item.Operations at a seller client side 601, a buyer client side 603, and aserver side 602 are shown in FIG. 6C.

At block 654, a buyer generates a buyer-proposed price for an offereditem listed on the commerce system 10. The buyer-proposed offer pricemay be the price the buyer is willing to pay for the listed item, andthe seller may accept or reject.

At block 656, the commerce system 10 receives the buyer-proposed offerprice for the listing. At block 658, the commerce system 10 notifies theseller of the buyer-proposed offer price (e.g., via email, instantmessaging, and update of listing, among other well known mechanisms).

At block 660, the seller receives the notification of the buyer-proposedoffer price. At decision block 662, the seller declines or accepts thebuyer-proposed offer price as an agreed-upon price of the item. At block664, the seller transmits the indication of the acceptance or thedeclining of the buyer-proposed offer price to the network-basedcommerce system 10.

At block 666, the network-based commerce system 10, receives theindication of the seller's acceptance or declining of the buyer-proposedprice as an agreed-upon price. At block 668, if the seller accepts thebuyer-proposed price, control passes to block 670. At block 668, if theseller declines the buyer-proposed price, control passes to block 674and the auction continues. At block 670, the auction price-settingprocess is stopped. At block 672, a transaction obligations areestablished between the buyer and the seller. It should also beunderstood that although the seller may not accept the buyer-proposedoffer price, the seller may, in the alternative, adjust the reserveprice and/or seller fixed-price offer of the listing of the item, asdescribed above. In this way, the buyer and seller may negotiate toreach a mutually agreed to sale price.

FIG. 6D is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to adjust a reserve price and/orseller fixed-price offer for a listing, based on a buyer request. Atblock 674, the buyer generates a request for the seller to adjust thepredefined seller fixed-price offer of the listing and/or the reserveprice of the listing. In this way, the buyer attempts to negotiate withthe seller to lower the reserve price and/or fixed-price during anauction price-setting process, lest, for example, the auctionprice-setting process terminates without a winner.

At block 676, the network-based commerce system 10 receives the buyerrequest to adjust the reserve price and/or seller fixed-price offer. Atblock 678, the network-based commerce system 10 notifies the seller ofthe request to adjust the seller fixed-price offer and/or reserve price(e.g., via email, instant messaging, among other notificationmechanisms).

At block 680, the seller receives the buyer's request to adjust theseller fixed-price offer and/or reserve price. At block 682, the sellerindicates whether to adjust the fixed-price offer and/or reserve price.At block 684, the buyer transmits the indication to adjust the reserveprice and/or seller fixed-price offer proposed by the buyer.

At block 686, the network-based commerce system 10 receives theindication to adjust the reserve price and/or seller fixed-price offer.At block 688, if the indication is to accept the buyer-proposedadjustment, control passes to block 690. If the indication is not toaccept the buyer-proposed adjustment, control passes to block 694. Atblock 694, the buyer (and any other relevant party) are notified of therejection and the auction continues.

At block 690, the network-based commerce system 10 adjusts the reserveprice and/or seller fixed-price offer based on the buyer adjustmentrequest. The adjustment of the reserve price and/or seller fixed-priceoffer may be published to the client machine 38 using page server 12 ancommerce system 10.

At block 692, the buyer is notified of the adjustment of the sellerfixed-price offer and/or reserve price. In one embodiment, anyadditional relevant party may also be notified of the adjustment of theseller fixed-price offer and/or reserve price. The notification may bevia email, instant messaging, etc.

At block 696, the buyer receives the notification of the adjustment ofthe seller fixed-price offer and/or reserve price (e.g., via email,instant messaging, among other examples)

FIG. 7A is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to facilitate exchanging reserveprice information of a seller and proxy bid information of a buyer. Theprocess flow of FIG. 7A is separated into a seller client side 701, abuyer client side 703, and a server side 702. This process flow allows abuyer and seller to agree to exchange proxy and reserve priceinformation with a view to promoting establishment of a mutually agreedto price for the item. In one embodiment, this process flow may beinitiated upon the server 702 inviting a seller and/or a buyer toexchange proxy bid information and reserve price information. Theseinvitation may be provided on the listings to the related items beforeor during the auction price-setting process.

At block 712, the seller indicates a willingness to exchange reserveprice information related to a listing if the buyer agrees to provideproxy bid information. This indication is sent to the commerce system10.

At block 715, the network-based commerce system 10 receives anindication that the seller is willing to exchange the reserve priceinformation of a listing if the buyer is willing to agree to provideproxy bid information.

At block 721, a buyer indicates a willingness to exchange proxy bidinformation related to the listing if the seller agrees to provide thecurrent reserve price of the listing for the item. This indication issent to the commerce system 10.

At block 718, the network-based commerce system 10 receives anindication that the buyer is willing to exchange the proxy bidinformation of a listing if the buyer is willing to agree to providereserve price information.

At block 720, a determination is made at the commerce system 10 whetherboth the seller and the buyer agree to exchange the reserve priceinformation and proxy bid information, respectively. Following apositive determination at block 720, the reserve price information issent to the seller and the proxy bid information is sent to the buyer atblock 727.

At block 730, the seller receives the buyer proxy bid information.

At block 736, the buyer receives the seller reserve price information.

This exchange seller and buyer information could occur during or afteran auction. In one embodiment, upon conclusion of an auction, anotification (e.g., email, etc.) is sent to the seller and/or buyerinviting them to exchange reserve price and/or proxy bid information tothe other party. In one embodiment, a notification could be triggeredwhen the proxy and reserve prices are within an predetermined proximity(e.g., a 20% proximity) to each other. Further, these exchanges could bemaintained as private communications between a particular buyer and aseller. Alternatively, an exchange offer could be indicated in thelisting, either during or after the auction. It should be noted thatthis concept is mutually exclusive with the publication of the proxy andreserve prices during an auction.

It should be understood that the commerce system 10 may allow the sellerand/or buyer to communicate their desire to exchange informationdirectly to the other party. The receiving party may then reply with anindication whether to accept the invitation to exchange information ornot.

In one embodiment, the auction facility 10 automatically displays theproxy bid (e.g., the maximum amount a buyer is willing to bid topurchase an item on a listing) while the proxy bid amount is less than areserve price.

In one embodiment, the seller would be able to communicate differentprices (e.g., reserve or seller fix-price offer) to different sellers,depending upon various conditions. For example, where the buyer had anexcellent reputation, or utilized a specific payment service (e.g.,PayPal), the seller may wish to offer a discounted price. Further, otherfactors such as shipping etc. could be built into the price, in whichcase the seller could communicate different prices based on buyerlocation. Essentially, this mechanism would allow the seller to engagein multiple parallel negotiations with individual buyers and differentconditions possibly applying to each buyer. This mechanism could providea “second phase” in the negotiation process whereby, followingestablishment of a base price at the close of an auction orfixed-price-setting process, the buyer and seller could engage inseparate negotiations regarding the shipping or other charges.

FIG. 7B is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to one exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to facilitate publishing reserveprice information based on criteria. The process flow of FIG. 7B isseparated into a seller client side 701 and a server side 702.

At block 739, a seller indicates a willingness to publish a reserveprice listing of an item that is otherwise hidden from the buyers on thecommerce system 10, upon completion of certain criteria. This concept ismotivated by the understanding that, in a below-reserve situation,buyers are not bidding against other buyers but in fact bidding againstthe reserve price. It should be understood that when the high proxy bidexceeds the reserve price, the proxy bid information is no longerpublished so as to allow buyer to compete against each other with therequired anonymity. In one embodiment, the auction may be limited incertain commerce categories (e.g., high value categories), or that couldotherwise be optional enabled/disabled by a seller.

At block 742, the commerce system 10 receives an indication to publishthe reserve price upon the completion of the given criteria. At block745, a determination is made whether the criteria have been met. Thecriteria may be, for example, to publish either or both of the proxy andreserve prices if the high proxy bid is less than the reserve price. Ifthe criteria have been met, control passes to block 748. At block 748,the commerce system 10 publishes the reserve price and/or proxy bidinformation for the item. If the criteria have not been met, controlpasses to block 751. At block 751, the commerce system 10 removes orretract the reserve price and/or proxy bid information from publicationvia a page server 12.

It should be understood that the bidder may be notified (e.g., viaemail, instant messenger, update of listing, etc) of the publication ofthe reserve price and/or proxy (at block 748) or the removal ofpublication (at block 751).

It should also be understood that the commerce system 10 may publish theproxy bid without receiving an indication from the seller. In thisfashion, the commerce system 10 publishes the proxy bid (e.g., themaximum amount the buyer is willing to pay for an item) regardless ofthe seller's desire.

FIG. 7C is a flowchart illustrating a method, according to the exemplaryembodiment of the present invention, to publish a fixed-price offerduring an auction. The process flow of FIG. 7C is separated into aseller client side 701 and a server side 702.

At block 760, the seller indicates a desire to publish a predefinedfixed-price offer for an item listed for auction when a specificcriterion has been met. The seller fixed-price offer may be madeavailable, or alternatively the seller fixed-price offer may bepublished, once the actual or proxy bids have reached a certain value.Accordingly, the seller fix-price offer is not published until thispoint. Again, notification would be utilized to advise buyers orwatchers that the seller fix-price offer auction had been activated, orthat the seller fix-price offer had been published. For example, thespecific criteria may be not to display the seller fixed-price offeruntil a specific time has lapse on the auction.

At block 763, the commerce system 10 receives the indication from thebuyer not to display the fixed-price offer until the criteria has beenmet. At block 767, a determination is made whether the criteria has beenmet. If the criteria has been met, then control passes to block 770. Ifthe criteria is not met, control passes to block 733. At block 770, thecommerce system 10 publishes the fixed-price offer related of thelisting describing an item during auctioned.

At block 773, a determination is made whether the auction has ended. Ifthe auction has not ended, control passes returns to block 767. If theauction has ended, control passes to block 775.

FIG. 8 illustrates a process flow of one embodiment of a list analyzer.The processes are separated into the processes of a seller client side801, a buyer client side 803, and a server side 802. The list analyzerprocess reviews a listing of an offering submitted by a seller and makessuggestions to how the listing may be improved to increase thelikelihood of a sale resulting.

At block 812, a seller prepares a listing of offering at the clientmachine 38. At block 815, the seller submits the listing to the commercesystem 10. At block 818, the commerce system 818 receives the listing ofthe offering. At block 821, the commerce system 10 analyzes the listing.For example, the commerce system 10 could review the submitted listingby automatically checking the fields and setting for completeness (e.g.,amount of text description, photo on listing, etc.), suggest formatting(e.g., bold type), suggest text, suggest images, and/or a pricingstrategy (e.g., use a seller fixed-price with no reserve priceinformation).

At block 824, if suggestions are to be made to the seller based on theanalysis of the listing, control passes to block 827. If, at block 824,suggestions are not to be made to the seller based on the analysis ofthe listing, control passes to block 830.

At block 830, the auction continues.

At block 827, the suggestions are sent to the seller. At block 833, theseller receives the suggestions. At block 836, the seller determineswhether to accept the suggestions. If, at block 836, the seller,determines to accept the suggestions, control returns to block 815 andthe updated listing is sent to the commerce system 10.

In one embodiment, the analyzing of the listing at block 821 may checkfor a valid VIN number (Vehicle Identification Number) when listing avehicle to reduce the insurance premiums. The commerce system 10 maycheck the vehicle VIN against a vehicle history database to double checkagainst title fraud, odometer rollback, etc. In one embodiment, thevehicle database may be stored locally on the commerce system 10 orremote on a third party database, such as an auction insurance company.If the vehicle history database is stored remotely, the remote databasecould report back problems to the commerce system 10.

FIG. 9 illustrates a process flow of one embodiment of aseller-controlled publication of question and answer sets. The processesare separated into the processes of a seller client side 901, a buyerclient side 903, and a server side 902. At block 912, a bidder submits aquestion about a listing to a seller via the commerce system 10. Atblock 915, the commerce system 10 receives the question. At block 918,the commerce system 10 sends the question to the seller of the listing.At block 921, the seller receives the question. At block 924, if theseller determines to publish the question on the listing, control passesto block 927. At block 924, if the seller determines not to publish thequestion and an answer to the question on the listing, control passes toblock 933. At block 927, the commerce system 10 receives the indicationto publish the question and answer. At block 930, the question andanswer are published in association with the listing via the page server12. At block 933, the seller sends the question and answer to thebidder. At block 936, the commerce system 10, receives the question andanswer. At block 939, the commerce system sends the question and answerto the buyer that asked the question. At block 942, the bidder receivesthe question and answer.

It should be understood that the bidder need not send the question tothe seller about the listing via the commerce system 10. Alternatively,the bidder may communicate the question directly to the seller (e.g.,via email), and also, the bidder may determine to communicate the answerto the question directly to the bidder. In this fashion, the seller mayprovide different responses to the same question to different bidders.

FIG. 10 provides an exemplary embodiment of the user interface 500created at block 110 in FIG. 3 to relay offering options to the sellerand collect information on the seller's item. The user interface 500gives the seller the option to allow a bidder to buy the item at aseller fixed-price offer 514.

FIG. 11 provides an exemplary embodiment of the category list 517 andsearch criteria request generated by block 420 in FIG. 4. A buyer cangenerate search criteria (block 440) by typing the search criteria(block 516).

FIG. 12 provides an exemplary embodiment of the item index pagegenerated at block 460 in FIG. 4. A possible placement of thefixed-price purchase process availability icon 518 is shown next to theitem. Also displayed in the embodiment of the item index page is a listof prices 514 which could either be the current bid or the sellerfixed-price offer if available. It is understood that the invention isnot limited to the fields as displayed in FIG. 12.

FIG. 13 shows an exemplary embodiment of the markup language documentgenerated at block 270 in FIG. 5. Regular auction panel 503 is generated(blocks 240 and 400). Fixed price purchase process panel 504 isgenerated (block 250) in FIG. 5. The buyer can submit a bid 520 or,depending on the availability of the fixed price purchase process, canstart the fixed price purchase process in panel 504.

FIG. 14 shows a diagrammatic representation of machine in the exemplaryform of a computer system 1000 within which a set of instructions, forcausing the machine to perform any one of the methodologies discussedabove, may be executed. In alternative embodiments, the machine maycomprise a network router, a network switch, a network bridge, PersonalDigital Assistant (PDA), a cellular telephone, a web appliance, set-topbox (STB) or any machine capable of executing a sequence of instructionsthat specify actions to be taken by that machine.

The computer system 1000 includes a processor 1002, a main memory 1006and a static memory 1008, which communicate with each other via a bus1024. The computer system 1000 may further include a video display unit1012 (e.g., a liquid crystal display (LCD) or a cathode ray tube (CRT)).The computer system 1000 also includes an alphanumeric input device 1014(e.g., a keyboard), a cursor control device 1016 (e.g., a mouse), a diskdrive unit 1018, a signal generation device 1022 (e.g., a speaker) and anetwork interface device 1010.

The disk drive unit 1018 includes a machine-readable medium 1020 onwhich is stored a set of instructions (i.e., software) 1004 embodyingany one, or all, of the methodologies described above. The software 1004is also shown to reside, completely or at least partially, within themain memory 1006 and/or within the processor 1002. The software 1004 mayfurther be transmitted or received via the network interface device1010. For the purposes of this specification, the term “machine-readablemedium” shall be taken to include any medium which is capable of storingor encoding a sequence of instructions for execution by the machine andthat cause the machine to perform any one of the methodologies of thepresent invention. The term “machine-readable medium” shall accordinglybe taken to included, but not be limited to, solid-state memories,optical and magnetic disks, and carrier wave signals. Further, while thesoftware is shown in FIG. 14 to reside within a single device, it willbe appreciated that the software 1004 could be distributed acrossmultiple machines or storage media, which may include themachine-readable medium.

In the foregoing detailed description, the method and system of thepresent invention has been described with reference to specificexemplary embodiments thereof. It will, however, be evident that variousmodifications and changes may be made thereto without departing from thebroader scope of the present invention. In particular, the separateblocks of the various block diagrams represent functional blocks ofmethods or apparatuses and are not necessarily indicative of physical orlogical separations or of an order of operation inherent in the scope ofthe present invention. For example, the blocks of FIGS. 3, 4, 5A, 5B,6A, 6B, 6C, 6D, 7A, 7B, and 7C, 8, and 9 represent portions of a method,which, in some embodiments, may be reordered or may be organized inparallel rather than in a linear or step-wise fashion. The presentspecification and figures are accordingly to be regarded as illustrativerather than restrictive.

1. A network-based commerce system including: a processor coupled to amemory through a bus; and a fixed price-setting process executed fromthe memory by the processor to cause the processor to automaticallypublish at least one of a proxy bid information and a reserve price if ahigh proxy bid is less than the reserve price, the proxy bid informationand the reserve price being associated with a listing for an item duringa network-based auction price-setting process.
 2. The network-basedcommerce system of claim 1, wherein the fixed price process furthercauses the processor to automatically unpublishing the proxy bidinformation upon the high proxy bid exceeding the reserve price.
 3. Thenetwork-based commerce system of claim 1, wherein the fixed priceprocess further causes the processor to facilitate a request for anadjustment of a fixed price offer associated with a seller of thelisting for the item, the request to be sent to the seller.
 4. Thenetwork-based commerce system of claim 1, wherein the publication isperformed during the auction price-setting process.
 5. The network-basedcommerce system of claim 1, wherein the publication is performed afterthe auction price-setting process.
 6. The network-based commerce systemof claim 1, further comprising: automatically notifying a buyer when thereserve price is published.
 7. The network-based commerce system ofclaim 1, wherein the fixed price-setting process further causes theprocessor, when publishing to publish for view by a specific buyer only.8. The network-based commerce system of claim 1, wherein the fixedprice-setting process further causes the processor, when publishing todisplay the maximum bid amount a buyer is willing to bid to purchase anitem on the listing.
 9. A network-based commerce system including: ameans for automatically publishing at least one of a proxy bidinformation and a reserve price if a high proxy bid is less than thereserve price, the proxy bid information and the reserve price beingassociated with a listing for an item during a network-based auctionprice-setting process; and a means for storing the listing.
 10. Thenetwork-based commerce system of claim 9, further comprising: a meansfor automatically unpublishing the proxy bid information upon the highproxy bid exceeding the reserve price.
 11. The network-based commercesystem of claim 9, further comprising: a means for facilitating arequest for an adjustment of a fixed price offer associated with aseller of the listing for the item, the request to be sent to theseller.
 12. The network-based commerce system of claim 9, wherein thepublication is performed during the auction price-setting process. 13.The network-based commerce system of claim 9, wherein the publication isperformed after the auction price-setting process.
 14. The network-basedcommerce system of claim 9, further comprising: a means forautomatically notifying a buyer when the reserve price is published. 15.The network-based commerce system of claim 9, wherein the publishingincludes publishing for view by a specific buyer only.
 16. Thenetwork-based commerce system of claim 9, wherein publishing includesdisplaying the maximum bid amount a buyer is willing to bid to purchasean item on the listing.
 17. A machine-readable medium havinginstructions to cause a machine to perform a method to facilitateoperation of a network-based commerce system, the method including:automatically publishing at least one of a proxy bid information and areserve price if a high proxy bid is less than the reserve price, theproxy bid information and the reserve price being associated with alisting for an item during a network-based auction price-settingprocess.
 18. The machine-readable medium of claim 17, furthercomprising: automatically unpublishing the proxy bid information uponthe high proxy bid exceeding the reserve price.
 19. The machine-readablemedium of claim 17, further comprising: facilitating a request for anadjustment of a fixed price offer associated with a seller of thelisting for the item, the request to be sent to the seller.
 20. Themachine-readable medium of claim 17, wherein the publication isperformed during the auction price-setting process.
 21. Themachine-readable medium of claim 17, wherein the publication isperformed after the auction price-setting process.
 22. Themachine-readable medium of claim 17, further comprising: automaticallynotifying a buyer when the reserve price is published.
 23. Themachine-readable medium of claim 17, wherein the publishing includespublishing for view by a specific buyer only.
 24. The machine-readablemedium of claim 17, wherein publishing includes displaying the maximumbid amount a buyer is willing to bid to purchase an item on the listing.25. A method to facilitate operation of a network-based commerce system,the method including: automatically publishing at least one of a proxybid information and a reserve price if a high proxy bid is less than thereserve price, the proxy bid information and the reserve price beingassociated with a listing for an item during a network-based auctionprice-setting process.
 26. The method of claim 25, further comprising:automatically unpublishing the proxy bid information upon the high proxybid exceeding the reserve price.
 27. The method of claim 25, furthercomprising: facilitating a request for an adjustment of a fixed priceoffer associated with a seller of the listing for the item, the requestto be sent to the seller.
 28. The method of claim 25, wherein thepublication is performed during the auction price-setting process. 29.The method of claim 25, wherein the publication is performed after theauction price-setting process.
 30. The method of claim 25, furthercomprising: automatically notifying a buyer when the reserve price ispublished.
 31. The method of claim 25, wherein the publishing includespublishing for view by a specific buyer only.
 32. The method of claim25, wherein publishing includes displaying the maximum bid amount abuyer is willing to bid to purchase an item on the listing.